(1) POSH vs. (5) SIENNA MILLER
FABULOUS, THIS MATCH-UP. Our gal Vicks might even call it major. A battle of the Brits. But can Posh fight off the young upstart? Sienna is strong in the ways of the fug. But is she this strong?
Remember those halcyon days before Posh took out the extensions because David kept yanking them out in the heat of the moment? These are good times -- with Posh frolicking around Los Angeles, pretending to care about Scientology a little, but mostly dressing up Katie Holmes like a doll. But these were good times too, at the height of her WAG-dom. Posh, in other words, is kind of a classic.
And then, like Maude, there's Sienna:
Miller is one of those woman whose face always surprises me. She is truly SO PRETTY, but I only tend to notice this in her movies, because when she's out and about, I'm staring at her wack-ass outfits: the twine tied up the outside of her pants, the crazy boots, the hats my god the hats. Why does she do that?
I have to go for Posh on this. While Sienna looks relaxed, Posh always looks like a waxed doll. Her personlaity doesn't make her any less freaky in her fashion outfits.
I kind of love how plastic Posh's boobs (and I 'spose everything else) look.
That picture of Posh is PRICELESS!
i... cant... vote.....
no, not because i can't decide - but because there isn't a votie thingie? i like posh
Technical difficulties gremlins strike again!
...And on the one I didn't have to deliberate, even. Sienna is tacky and awkward, but Posh is far her superior in fug.
I can't vote either as the voting thingie does not exist on my computer either.
If I could vote though, it would definitely be for Posh. She is the queen fug and proud of it from what I can tell!
Yes, where is the poll-enabler? I desperately want to cast my vote!
My goodness, we're quick!
I'm for Posh. But, like lynnae, I can't vote!
I am unable to vote for Sienna over Posh for any reason, even though I think Posh is more fabulous than fug.
Yes, please, fix the "votie thing", as right now there isn't one, and I'd like to put in my two cents for Sienna. This girl has given me the creeps since the first time I ever saw her!
Need to votee, have to fug someone nooooooooowwwww!!!!
Oh, my god. See that outfit Sienna Miller is wearing in that photo? I wore that exact outfit, without the weird bronze Beadazzler studs, my sophomore year of college. But I had punky hair and an armful of those black rubber bracelets that everyone wore in the late '80s.
I feel embarrassed. Both for me, and for her.
We're fixing it!!
Click on the "poll by twiggs" link at the bottom of the page and it'll take you to a place where you can vote.
Then, vote for Sienna!
I think I fixed it? It's showing up for me now.
What is UP this week? Is something in retrograde? I don't usually believe in that stuff... unless it's convenient. F' YOU, RETROGRADEY THING.
Going through SM's archives I realized that the only time she looks nice is with a coat on. That's just sad! Posh is totally fierce and gets a pass.
Going through SM's archives I realized that the only time she looks nice is with a coat on. That's just sad! Posh is totally fierce and gets a pass.
I reloaded the page and the vote thing appeared.
Posh. Because she doesn't look like she's eaten in months. Because of her abortive appearance on "The Daily Show" a billion years ago. Because she doesn't look comfortable...ever. Because she is the Queen of chav culture. Because of what she wore in the Spice Girls come-back video. (What was it..."Headlines"?) Because she seems to have chiseled her bitchface from premolded space-age polymers.
Though she seemed almost charming in the season finale of "Project Runway." But it's too little, too late.
The linen strapless jumpsuit gave Sienna the win. At least you know that Posh is predictable. She will show up in something tight, looking ridiculously skinny and slightly orange, and probably use the word "major" a little too liberally. With Sienna, you never know what she will look like, but you know it is going to be cra-azy.
Nasty old Sienna Miller. Again, a tough category, but Sienna wins, if only for shameless promotion of Ugg boots. I'm pretty sure Posh is just pastiching herself....or Barbie dolls from a farway planet.
Posh-Vicky-Mrs. Beckham all the way to the top. My money is on this girl to take it all. She's determined, she's ambitious, she'll stop at nothing.
let's get this competition back to the glory days when "fug" actually meant something. when it was shameful as oppose to a cause for celebration.
vote miller for the win!
I have to say Posh if only b/c Sienna at least mixes it up a bit. Posh is pretty limited to two looks: emaciated mean person in skin tight pants and poky clavicles or emaciated mean person in almost OK but ultimately trashy dress...with poky clavicles.
Noooooooo! Sienna's not in the lead??? Why not? She's so, so very unattractive fashion-wise! Posh is at least campy! Does camp not count anymore? Alas!
Haha, I love how tight this is getting at the end!!! I'm praying for a Peldon/Sevigny final 2.
But... Posh can pull it together sometimes and look totally fierce, and she's married to Becks, and she (in addition to Sporty, Ginger, Baby, and Scary) played a huge part in my adolescence.
Can't say the same for Sienna... she's just a refried version of Boho chic that Kate Moss patented years ago. Even though she is gorgeous, that doesn't excuse her fugliness!
O the pain of not being able to vote the both of them off to a faraway planet in a tiny space capsule.
I think it was the terrible humorlessless of Posh's superconcentrated fug that pushed her over the edge, for me. Sienna is a ghastly, self-infatuated fug machine, but at least she smiles halfway convincingly once in a while. The laserlike, robotic intensity of Posh adds a terrible frisson of fear to the fug.
sienna ties her shoes over her pants! at least Posh always has great shoes.
Posh all the way - if only because of the truly stupendous amount of money she has spent to look that way!
I kind of dig Posh - I feel like she gets the joke and wants to be a part of it. And since I despise the dress-over-jeans look, Sienna got my vote.
If the object of this contest is to be insulted by winning, then my vote goes to Sienna. Nothing against her personally, but she DOES tend to be a fashion trainwreck just rolling out of bed--despite her complete cuteness and potential for the contrary (just get over Jude already, honey--he's a hottie who is meant to be enjoyed by all). True, Posh does look like a silicone "fembot" (LOVED that comment!) and her boobs resemble scoops of spray-tanned ice cream perched atop any number of sherbet-colored fabrics (I didn't hate the neon green-yellow!), but she ultimately gets props for creating her her own unstoppable brand of Fierce v. Fug for 2 irrefutable reasons: 1) that rockin' asymmetrical platinum-blonde haircut and 2) Becks--no explanation needed. Sienna, ditch the Uggs and the bizarre ragamuffin couture and HIRE A STYLIST! I dare say a good stylist would basically render this entire competition null and void, so. . . just forget I said that! This is way too entertaining!
Sienna, as i am still recovering from the horror of seeing her at the Golden Globes with that half-bun hair i wore at volleyball practice in high school accentuated with the fake-hair Heidi braid pinned to her head, and topped off with that self-satisfied look she always swans around in. Posh is just a wing nut - Sienna is smug in her fug and there is nothing worse than that.
I just went through EVERY single photo of BOTH of them in the archives. Oh, this is hard -- SO very hard; but not as hard as Posh's sharp iron clavicle. She frightens me and doesn't appear to be from our earth. I don't think she (nor her inexplicable wardrobe) is fair competition against mere mortal beings.
Therefore, I gotta fug Sienna.
Thanks, Heather and Jessica, for fun fugging Friday!
Posh now, Posh forever.
And let's not forget that she was actually a *judge* of fashion for this season's Project Runway. How? Why?
p.s. I'm a nerd, but... it's halcyon.
I *heart* Drdan. Well said.
Damn! Posh OWNS her fug. She FUGTASTIC. Sienna Miller is a bad Kate Moss knockoff and gets my vote because the girl just doesn't know when to say when.
I don't see how this is possible, the voting is relatively close! Posh is fabulously fug, while Sienna is just foul. If there was a contest between the two in which they had to make an outfit out of garbage bag Posh would belt it, shorten it, and add fabulous accessories (a la that bridesmaid dress in Ugly Betty) whereas the other one would add two more layers of garbage bags, 20 year old army boots, a straw hat and a couple of scarves, as well as the garbage that came inside the bag!
I love Posh. She's just so unnecessary, and ever since that Project Runway episode where she and Christian became SUPER-BFFS-OMG I've just adored her.
But Sienna is just such pretentious snob. You KNOW she wants to be relevant just so, so badly. argh.
WHAT IS GOING ON with her makeup in that photo of Sienna Miller? Is that blush color called "Mystic Tan"?
p.s. Jessica and Heather, thanks for this whole fug extravaganza. Awesome.
Sienna, sienna, sienna!!! Sienna fancies herself some kind of hipster icon, but she's just not. She's boring and vanilla. At least I'm actually interested in what Posh is going to do next. That and I secretly suspect that Posh probably a good person with really, really horrible taste. (except in men, of course)
Sienna is putting up quite the fight against Posh. Much closer than I thought it would be.
Oh no! Posh shouldn't be losing out to Sienna Miller! Posh is campy and ridiculous whereas Sienna is just a nightmare. I mean, like, wow. Y'know? WOW.
MECHA-Posh will surely crush her competition. I'd love to see her up against Sharon Stone actually. ooooooh ::shivers:
I LOVE Posh. And though I think she fugs much more elegantly than Sienna, and would vote for Sienna in a heartbeat if the winner received lifetime "you don't get to choose your clothing anymore, WE do" service, I just want Posh to win the whole thing. I think she'd actually love being the winner, and maybe parade the title around, while Sienna would probably just shrug and slink into some fuglier leggings.
Ah, but when Posh does it right, she does it RIGHT. I love the crisply-cut suits and the FABULOUS sunglasses. Love her or hate her, she never looks sloppy. Sienna ALWAYS looks sloppy and wrinkled, and is, therefore, the fugliest.
I can't believe Posh is winning. Posh HAS style, it may not be a human style, but she takes the fem-bot thing and works it. Sienna, on the other hand, is tacky, talentless and sometimes ickily dirty-looking. She is the ultimate fug in this contest, hands down.
I heart Posh and think she is fantastic, therefore canNOT bring myself to vote for her. I voted for Sienna's fugliness due to her constant STRAPPING HER SHOES OVERTOP OF HER PANTS (among other things ... but especially for the fecking shoe-strap-over-pant-leg-thing ... soo irritating).
And seriously, Posh is awesome. Even in her craziness, she's spectacular.
Is this really a debate? I mean, S. Mill is a total Kate Moss wannabe. And a poor one at that. Sienna looks like she smells of pachouli and cigs. Posh on the other hand smells like...... FABULOUS!!!! Posh Spice is the epitome of deliciousness, she of the steely gaze and sometimes inappropriatly timed runway walk. And how can you not love someone who vamps it up at the mother-luvin DMV?!?!
It should be Sienna simply cause she is wearing a Dress with Jeans! No.
Have to vote for Sienna because Posh has been on my side ever since I got her fabulous book for Christmas
Oh come on! At least Victoria has her own fabulous jaw dropping style, she didn't need to run out and nick someone-else's fugly look and then fug it even more. VB may get it wrong, but she has the guts to really push that fashion envelope so we don't have to.
Whereas Sienna took Kate Moss' look, then made it her mission to discover where they were storing the old costumes for "Worzel Gummidge", et voila a fug icon was born.
I have to go with Sienna. And, people, isn't this about FASHION in the end? I appreciate an earlier post whose author said s/he makes the tough decisions by asking which wardrobe would be the worst to own. I like that angle. I'm going with it from here on out!
I agree 100% with whomever said "Posh gets the joke and wants to be a part of it" EXACTLY! Posh knows what she's doing and lets be honest she is freaking stylish, campy and over the top...but still well done all around with the shiny hair, perfect manicures, perfect orange base coat, nice flattering make-up
Sienna is a mess that some how managed to trick the entire magazine industry into pretending she's an actress people give a crap about. How does she make it on the cover of MULTIPLE US Vogues??!?!?!? she is somebody who has no fans and no sense of style...truly fug inside and out
well dahlings, Posh at least is fugly in that fabulous, this-looks-hideously-expensive-because-it-IS way. Sienna looks like she robbed a sleeping homeless man, which she would probably do. Sienna is FUGGED
I was truly having a rough time with this. True, Posh is probably more fug, but she's also FABULOUS. Sienna, on the other hand, just wears really ugly clothes.
Posh brings the fug with those bolted on melon halves on her chest. She does create the illusion of high fashion but with her fake tan (aren't Brits supposed to be a bit pasty?) and fake tatas she sadly fails. I also believe that she cannot rock that particular bob. Way too severe on already severe woman.
Her only saving grace is Becks and she is not photographed with him nearly enough.
Sienna does have a pretty face but fugs up her body but right with her choice of clothing.
However, Posh is the ultimate fug in this contest.
Come ON! Posh is fabulous and over-the-top on purpose, like her fake-mom Joan Collins on Dynasty. Sienna is just a boring pseudo-hippie who thinks she's being edgy.
I really like Posh. Her outfits are crazy but she seems to think about them and actually be an expression of her. Sienna, dear lord, just seems a little retarded. Though I do like that these are her own mistakes and not a stylist. At least it's because she has bad taste not that she pays someone with bad taste to fug her.
i love posh - she embodies... something. sienna miller is just sort of sloppy or trashy or something. trying hard not to look like she wants us to look at her, but you know she does. at least vickie owns up to it. she's crazy, but it works for her. i voted for sienna. nothing redeeming there.
Gosh, when you laid out all the Sienna tomfuggery, my finger trembled over the vote key for a nanosecond, however, I could never in good faith deny Posh, the Queen of Fug, her due. She fugs so deliciously!
While Sienna does dress rather horribly, she bores me. Posh on the other hand is like Velcro, adhering my eyeballs to the computer screen. Posh=fugly goodness
i am utterly horrified to discover that i LOVE THEM BOTH. I really, truly do. WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!? Why do i live for the crazy eye-searing moments when Posh will inflict her day-glo boobage on us? Why do I yearn for more of Sienna's quasi-downsy layers and tights and shorts over tights and boots of all shapes and heights...i am sick. i need help. I can't choose.
Posh is, at least, well groomed (well, er, except for the orangey cast). And, she is glamorous in a strange, bobbleheaded way.
The only thing that made me lean toward Posh was that she looked BETTER as a Spice Girl ("the little Gucci dress, the little Gucci dress or the little Gucci dress?") than she does now. That's frightening. However, in a contest of glamorous vs. homeless I will fug homeless every time. My vote goes to Ms. Miller.
Sienna is just being a born too late hippie. She is pretty so she can do it. We all know what it would look like on one of lesser looks or older years- like squirrel poo.
But POSH -- she really tries to look glamourous and Joan Collinsesque; she tires like hellllllll
however it just looks scarey, not posh. I mean, who has shiny boobs like that?
Plus, Sienna smiles all the time, as one should.
i cant help it. i heart posh. die sienna miller. or, you know, dont die, but just go away. MORE POSH!
Just for today (just for this minute?) I'm going to base my vote on "who do I wish would never wear their current clothes again." Posh is hideous, but as many have said, she's fabulously hideous. The world would be a little darker and sadder if she invested in more classic clothes. But if Sienna put on some decent clothes for once... now that would be an improvement for everyone concerned. You can use the same reasoning for Sharon S. vs. Fugliette Lewis. If Sharon S would clean up her act, she'd be a terrific looking queen diva. If Juliette cleaned up her act, she'd be sort of ordinary and noone would care. So, votes to Sharon and Sienna today...
Just for today (just for this minute?) I'm going to base my vote on "who do I wish would never wear their current clothes again." Posh is hideous, but as many have said, she's fabulously hideous. The world would be a little darker and sadder if she invested in more classic clothes. But if Sienna put on some decent clothes for once... now that would be an improvement for everyone concerned. You can use the same reasoning for Sharon S. vs. Fugliette Lewis. If Sharon S would clean up her act, she'd be a terrific looking queen diva. If Juliette cleaned up her act, she'd be sort of ordinary and noone would care. So, votes to Sharon and Sienna today...
This was a tough one. I almost picked Posh for obvious reasons, but the decided to go with Sienna Miller because she just always looks so sloppy.
Nooo! Posh can't be beat by Sienna Miller! c'mon! Posh is fantastic, in a "I wish she and Becks were my neighbors so I could see her crazy outfits and his hotness as they come and go" kind of way.
Sienna Miller is just a mess. Everyone, vote for the Sienster. seriously.
(I'd like to add: Hooray for the best March madness bracket EVAH! I heart GFY and these polls have brightened my week!)
Much as I want to vote for Posh and her pair of bolt-ons, I have to say Mrs. B has her style *and* rocks it. Doesn't matter that her style is pretty out there; it's still style with a capital S.
Sienna just looks like she slapped some velcro on her body and rolled around in her closet to see what would stick.
Posh = fab. Sianna = sad.
I totally agree with previous posters - Sienna is a Kate Moss wannabe who is pretentious and lame. Everyone in the magazine world keeps trying to tell us how "important" she is and what an "icon" she is. When will they get it? We are not interested! This matchup reminds me of the J. Lo - Beyonce matchup. J. Lo and Posh are crazy, over the top, diva fabulous. Beyonce and Sienna are just fug.
It seems to come down here to formal fug versus casual fug, ironed vs. wrinkled. And, even though it's Friday, I have to vote for formal. Posh's fug is so much more planned, and not just a sloppy accident. Her fashion world is eerily parallel to ours, like, what if those Pointer Sisters/Funkadelic outer-space outfits of the seventies had really caught on and influenced today's everyday wear? I mean, the woman stands out even shoulder-to-shoulder with the other Spice Girls, and that's saying something.
When is fug no longer fug? When it is ART, when it is POETRY, when it has the stark and complete internal logic of an elegant mathematical equation. Posh generates her own individual twilight-zone force-field within which, actually, what she is wearing makes PERFECT, obvious sense, and what everyone else is wearing is entirely beside the point. Sienna, on the other hand, excels at fugorama that is both careless and gratingly self-conscious (that's gotta be tough to pull off).
Unless - I'm becoming a little confused - is "fug" still deprecatory or or actually a compliment now? Because clearly, there is Fabulous Fug. Are we voting for the most fabulous fug or the most fugly fug?
Posh is colorful. And FIERCE. Sienna is boring + sloppy. I want to see more technicolor craaazzy!
Posh actually works it better than Sienna in this scenario, but Posh is going all the way.
When is fug no longer fug? When it is ART, when it is POETRY, when it has the stark and complete internal logic of an elegant mathematical equation. Posh generates her own individual twilight-zone force-field within which, actually, what she is wearing makes PERFECT, obvious sense, and what everyone else is wearing is entirely beside the point. Sienna, on the other hand, excels at fugorama that is both careless and gratingly self-conscious (that's gotta be tough to pull off).
Unless - I'm becoming a little confused - is "fug" still deprecatory or or actually a compliment now? Because clearly, there is Fabulous Fug. Are we voting for the most fabulous fug or the most fugly fug?
Wow. This is seriously tough. I went with Sienna because I think she really is trying to do the relaxed art chick thing but always gets it WRONG in the frumpy direction. Posh to me is just too fabulous. Also I just had to note that my favorite post ever was the one with Sienna and Jude Law where you wrote: "Dear Sienna and Jude: WE DON'T CARE ANYMORE. P.s. if we did care...." so great.
Posh, because she looks so mean and whorish all time. Good god, she's married to that pretty pretty man- I'd look happy all the live long day! Kind to bums and Peldons! Never mean a minute! But no, Posh is a Mean Girl.
Fug outside and in.
VICKY!!! We love Vicky. Even - and especially - in her reigning fugdom. She rules. OI!!
Miller - just, just... go away. If you had a career, then I might reconsider, but, oh you don't.
(And, yes, I know Vicky has no discernible career, but hey, she transcends. Or something.)
Sienna is faux-hippie fug; Posh is alien-species-praying-mantis-who-might-eat-you-if-she-actually-DID-eat-fug.
Sienna has a huge spread in this month's InStyle, which of course I only read at the nail salon, or at least that's the story I'm sticking to. She oooks really quite nice in it, or at least, nice for her, so I can't fug her now. Posh has those roboboobs that are forever threatening to escape their pods. I rather think those aren't even implants, but the spaceships used by the advance party of an army of tiny aliens bent on taking over the Earth, and only Posh's heroic efforts are keeping them inside -- barely -- her tops. That kind of dedication to the planet deserves a reward.
Oh, Hell. "looks nice." Sienna looks nice, not "oooks" nice. Although she might do that well to for all I know.
Sienna Miller is famous for looking crazy while Posh is STILL famous for looking crazy. I gotta give this one to Sienna - just barely!
Many have said it and I'll say it again: Posh owns the fug, the fug does not own Posh. Sienna is a sad and sorry fug mess who just has no clue whatsoever.
I'm torn, Posh is ridiculously fab, over-the-top and fun so I can't vote for her. Sienna's just blah so I don't want her to win anything over Posh.
I voted for Posh, but now I wish I hadn't.
Posh cares about fashion in a fabulously over-the-top wrongheaded way.
Sienna re-heats old trends in a surprisingly boring and ugly way. She just don't know how to dress herself nor, I suspect, does she care.
Sienna FTW. I am ashamed of my vote. :(
The vote has to go to Posh; see 4.21.05.
I had to go with Miller on this one - though, based on her effort, and seemingly endless need to be photographed doing nothing - I hated not giving props to Posh here - but the truth is Posh can sometimes look really good - or at least fashion forward - whereas I have never liked a single thing that Sienna Miller insists on flouncing around in public in - I mean seriously, by now there should have at least been one "well-played" outfit. And too, Sienna is going for the gold with the brown tarp thing of a dress -- the "I am just too depressed over Jude because I feel things - I feel things. . .deeply so I cannot be bothered to dress in anything other than this dark brown shapless tarp - such is my despair" outfit.
Sienna - what is with all the accessories? She doesn't have a clue, she just piles on one of each latest belt/hat/waistcoat/boot and hopes she looks cutting edge. She's young but not that young. In high school you can tell what year someone is in by how many different clips they are wearing in their hair, and Sienna looks like a first year. Posh is costumey but it always looks like an intended effect.
i voted for sienna, obvs. god. it's a crime to be born with so much and do so very little with it.
however, i do wonder if lady becks was crowned queen of the whole darn thing if she would a) find out about it and therefore b) deign to meet jessica and heather. she is totally in on the joke. for that, my darling fuggers, i would indeed change my vote.
Sienna's twine/bowler hat combo tips the scale to give her the win. There are just no words...
Sienna is just boring.
Posh looks like she's auditioning for the porn version of The Little Mermaid.
Ahahaha, the Maude reference is fantastic.
Siena all the way. I would rather see Posh run around town in just corsets, undies and her big ole' boobies than see Siena in those horrile fugging Peter Pan boots. That outfit (with the white/purple long sleeve shirt, shorts (I think) and vest is so insanely grotesque I can't see straight.
I'm sorry, I know I just posted, but I really feel the need to reiterate that she wore TWINE. With a BOWLER HAT. That is all.
Madonna Rips Off Kylie Again
http://www.judiciaryreport.com/madonna_ripping_off_kylie_again.htm
http://www.judiciaryreport.com/madonnas_new_album_cover_viciously_panned.htm
See now while I heart Posh, her wackiness I can accept. She's a Spice Girl. Sienna HAS NO EXCUSE. She's a mildly famous, sub-par actress.
Wotcha from Cockneyville. It's got to be Posh all the way. She's got nothing else on apart from wearing clothes and yet she still manages to get it so tragically wrong. Gor blimey guvnor, and all that.
Decisions, decisions! Sienne Miller is a walking disaster, but Posh scares me more and more with every picture I see. She is gradually getting worse, so she gets my vote for that -- I don't think Sienna Miller ever had a 'better' to start.
Posh bathes, Sienna doesn't.
Fug Sienna
Posh bathes, Sienna doesn't.
Fug Sienna
Posh, if you are reading this, which I suspect you are, you are FABULOUS! Go forth and continue to shock us girl. And give David a pat on his gorgeous tushie from me.
Sienna is definitely the fugliest. She has no idea whereas VB totally gets it.
Without Posh we would never have experienced any of her looks, she clearly serves a purpose in society. She's in on the joke and is more fab than fug. Sienna is just sucking up our O2.
Sienna outfugs Posh fo' sho'.
I love that my dig though Posh's archive brought me back to this: http://gofugyourself.typepad.com/go_fug_yourself/2007/01/katie_fugmes.html
Hahahahaha!
bitch, please. posh is going to win this entire fugtest and if she doesn't im going to boycott.
just kidding.
I voted Sienna. Posh obviously puts time into each and every one of her- let's say "costumes"- while I feel that Sienna sometimes just goes into her closet, closes her eyes, spins around and wears whatever she grabs first (perhaps fashion a belt from an ivy vine on the way out). Posh continually looks fierce; Sienna goes from actually pretty (rarely) to a complete slob.
I'm voting for Posh because her fug is a lot more interesting then Sienna's. Sienna is a Kate Moss wannabe, but Posh's brand of fug is original. Posh's fug is fun to watch, Sienna's fug is just boring.
See, at this point I have to say that I'm voting out of AFFECTION for fug versus actual fugliness -- they're all so worthy on fug merits in this round. And Posh is queen of my heart anyday over Sienna, who referred to my hometown in less-than-flattering terms (not that I had a lot of love prior to that).
Oh, Posh all the way. Because not only is her clothing fuggy, but she's fugged up her entire LOOK: hair, skin, boobs... it's a complete package!
if only i could forgive sienna for the control top pants/leggins with the matching ostrich feather top i would vote for poshless, but i am all out of forgiveness this far along in the competition.
Posh is awesomely fuggish.
Wait. I'm looking across the site but I'm not finding out what will actually HAPPEN for (or to) the winner. Are they being notified? Given a trophy (better yet, a pair of leggings or Uggs)? How is the winner to be commemorated?
oh man. this hurts.
posh spice is not of this world in her supreme fabulousness. i can't describe it. sienna, while beautiful, looks like she went through the lost and found pile at glastonbury.
sienna all the way. posh can be tacky but she wears her fug well. sienna....ugh.
Sienna = fuh-UHGly.
Posh = fug-TAC-ular.
As others have said, this (unlike the J-lo vs. Beyonce smackdown) is a true Rorschach test of fug: is it a Bedazzled tiara awarded to divas who inspire dropped jaws and "OH NO SHE DI'INT"s or a scarlet letter branded on those who inspire only shudders of revulsion? I gotta admit my voting rationale so far has flip-flopped depending on the contestants. Only now do I have to nail down, mentally, what this whole contest is about. Is true fugginess deliciously dreadful [Mrs. Becks] or just dreadful [the Millster]?
If only Intern George were here to pour me a soothing drink and rub my feet ... *then* I could decide.
Normally, um, usually, I would go with Posh. But it was the yellow bracelet used as an armband that sent me over the edge.
Yeah, I had to vote Sienna on this one. She's just so sloppy with the fug. So, "Hi, I rolled out of bed and this is what stuck to me so that's gonna be my outfit!"
is it wrong that I completely love Posh?
Sienna gets my vote...have to agree with the voter above who said campy must count for something. Posh looks clean and sometimes well put together, at the very least. I do think she is more charming than she appears in photos. Sienna on the other hand..completely classless, nasty personality, dirty looking..shiver.
Also, lets not forget the meaning of fug...if you think Posh is fierce in her fugness or fug-tabulous, you must vote Sienna because she is true fug.
Yeah, I went for posh here. She's so mannequin-like and botoxy. Sienna, yeah, has totally insane outfits, but like...she walks around in a big tshirt and sandals, Posh walks around looking like a Barbie Dominatrix.
Posh goes to great lengths to look fabulous. OK, so sometimes it is major fug, but Sienna Miller goes to great lenghts to look like she doesn't care. How sad is that? She should win the whole thing. And shame on her- because she is an absolutely gorgeous woman.